Andrea Captain Jack Sparrow Pirates of the Caribbean
BlairWaldorfQueenB  Poison & Wine The Vampire Diaries
Kahesha  Radioactive Defiance
KRL2008  It's All For You The Borgias
MariaPurt Nightmare Never Ends Once Upon a Time
RandHrShipper1  Katniss/Peeta: Mine is Yours The Hunger Games
Strawberrybisque  Hungry Like a Wolf Teen Wolf
Valika The Ballad of the Last Unicorn The Last Unicorn
ViDawn  My Sacrifice Supernatural

From the previous round:

Best AU, Most Sensual: Mazza - Faiths Last Name - Buffy the Vampire Slayer/Angel/Dollhouse

Most Humorous: Holdt - Brothers - Avengers/Thor

Submissions carried forward to the next round:

Best Couple, Romance, Effect: RandHrShipper - Katniss/Peeta - Mine is Yours (The Hunger Games)

Best Villain: MariaPurt - Nightmare Never Ends (Once Upon a Time)